Wednesday, March 03, 2010

Windows Azure and Cloud Computing Posts for 3/3/2010+

Windows Azure, SQL Azure Database and related cloud computing topics now appear in this weekly series.

 
Update 3/4/2010: Added a link to Jay Fry’s Two cloud computing Rorschach tests: 'legacy clouds' and the lock-in lesson post of 11/11/2009 about a November, 2009 San Francisco Cloud Computing Club meeting to the Windows Azure Infrastructure section.

Note: This post is updated daily or more frequently, depending on the availability of new articles in the following sections:

To use the above links, first click the post’s title to display the single article you want to navigate.

Cloud Computing with the Windows Azure Platform published 9/21/2009. Order today from Amazon or Barnes & Noble (in stock.)

Read the detailed TOC here (PDF) and download the sample code here.

Discuss the book on its WROX P2P Forum.

See a short-form TOC, get links to live Azure sample projects, and read a detailed TOC of electronic-only chapters 12 and 13 here.

Wrox’s Web site manager posted on 9/29/2009 a lengthy excerpt from Chapter 4, “Scaling Azure Table and Blob Storage” here.

You can now download and save the following two online-only chapters in Microsoft Office Word 2003 *.doc format by FTP:

  • Chapter 12: “Managing SQL Azure Accounts and Databases”
  • Chapter 13: “Exploiting SQL Azure Database's Relational Features”

HTTP downloads of the two chapters are available from the book's Code Download page; these chapters will be updated for the January 4, 2010 commercial release in February 2010. 

Azure Blob, Table and Queue Services

Learning Tree International offers Windows Azure Storage – Part 1, a brief tutorial about Azure blob storage in this 3/3/2010 post:

Software applications often need to store data and applications written for Windows Azure are no exception. Windows Azure provides three types of storage: queues, blobs and tables. As we have already seen something about queues in a prior post we now turn our attention to blobs and tables. Part 1 will cover blobs and Part 2 will cover tables.

Azure storage is based on REST. All storage objects are available through standard HTTP calls to a named URI. In practice, for .NET developers, though, it is probably easiest to just use the StorageClient assembly included as of version 1.1 of the Azure SDK.

Learning Tree also has posted the following introductory tutorials to promote their Windows Azure Platform Introduction: Programming Cloud-Based Applications. Other recent Azure-related posts are:

Saurabh Vartak shows you how to Create a Windows Azure Storage service to store the blobs in this 3/3/2010 post:

This article describes what Windows Azure Blobs are, how to create and display the same on our local environment and lastly how to create a Windows Azure Storage service to store the blobs on the cloud.

The article explains all of the above using a very simple web application, which will be uploading the files (blobs) to the storage. The web application will also be retrieving the URIs of the blobs which are already uploaded to the storage.

<Return to section navigation list> 

SQL Azure Database (SADB, formerly SDS and SSDS)

No significant articles today.

<Return to section navigation list> 

AppFabric: Access Control and Service Bus

Warwick Ashford reports RSA 2010: identity management key to cloud security, says Microsoft’s Scott Charney in this 3/3/2010 story for ComputerWeekly.com:

Identity is important on the internet, but this is amplified in the cloud, says Scott Charney, corporate vice-president of Microsoft's Trustworthy Computing Group.

"Identity and privacy will be key to cloud computing," he told the RSA Conference 2010 in San Francisco.

It is critical to produce technologies that better allow organisations to manage identity, he said, to provide more secure and private access to both onsite and cloud applications.

As part of efforts to enable a more trusted internet, Charney announced Microsoft's release of a preview of Microsoft's U-Prove technology.

U-Prove is designed to enable online providers to better protect privacy and enhance security through the minimal disclosure of information in online transactions.

"To encourage broad community evaluation and input, Microsoft is providing core portions of the U-Prove intellectual property under the Open Specification Promise," said Charney.

Announcing that Microsoft has made available open source software development kits in C# and Java, he challenged developers to create software to help protect individual privacy.

Charney said Microsoft is working with the Fraunhofer Institute to integrate U-Prove and other Microsoft technologies with the German Government's planned electronic identity cards.

According to Charney, the project envisages enabling [German] citizens to use their electronic identity cards as the basis for accessing online services with minimal disclosure of information. …

<Return to section navigation list>

Live Windows Azure Apps, APIs, Tools and Test Harnesses

My February 2010 Uptime Reports for OakLeaf Azure Test Harness Running in the South Central US Data Center post of 3/3/2010 reports:

For the first time, Mon.itor.us reported 100% uptime for the live OakLeaf Systems Azure Table Services Sample Project during an entire month, albeit a short month.

The post includes screen captures of Mon.itor.us and Pingdom uptime summaries for the month of February and links to three earlier monthly uptime reports.

The Windows Azure Team reports NASA and Microsoft Issue Pathfinder Innovation Challenge to Help Classify Mars Images in this 3/2/2010 post:

At PDC last fall, NASA and Microsoft made a number of announcements, including new data APIs in Codename Dallas and a Silverlight+ASP.NET MVC 2 site on the Windows Azure platform.  Did you know that we also launched a programming competition with NASA to help classify Mars images? 

Named after the first mission from Earth to send a rover to the surface of another planet, the goal of the Pathfinder Innovation Challenge is to find .NET developers who can help NASA classify the hundreds of thousands of images collected from the Spirit and Opportunity Mars Rover expeditions. This challenge provides developers with a unique opportunity to leverage their coding skills to help NASA, while also offering a chance to win some great prizes ranging from NASA swag and ZuneHDs to a trip to see the next Mars Rover launch.

The competition consists of four different Leagues; two, the Global Cooperation League and the Intelligence League are most relevant to .NET developers. The Global Cooperation League, uses Silverlight and NASA's Windows Azure-hosted APIs in Codename Dallas to build casual games designed to allow regular citizens to help classify images. Check out the counting craters application, Help Map Mars to see an example. The Intelligence League uses the power of the Windows Azure platform to create automated and efficient image-processing applications that can rapidly detect and label interesting objects within the Mars Expedition Rover images.

Full details about the competition can be found on the Pathfinder Innovation Challenge website. Be sure to check out the Learn How-Videos and Key Downloads page for additional information, official entry form and directions to acquire a token for accessing NASA APIs in Codename Dallas. 

Return to section navigation list> 

Windows Azure Infrastructure

Lori MacVittie claims “Microsoft Dynamic Infrastructure Toolkit for Systems Center (DIT-SC) is hopping forward, literally, into the network. With or without established standards, this dog is going to hunt” in her Microsoft Hops Into Infrastructure 2.0 post of 3/3/2010:

ms-sc-logo It takes time to develop standards, something we often overlook. When the foundational standards upon which the Internet were being developed there were (almost) no users, no broadband, and no real urgency to get something available. The adoption of disruptive, highly volatile technologies such as virtualization and cloud computing result in an environment in which today’s standards groups are not afforded the luxury of time. Organizations want, nay they need, standards now and if they aren’t forthcoming vendors and customers alike will move steadily forward with their own implementation.

The myriad “cloud APIs” submitted to various standards organization indicate this pattern of behavior has already begun and will continue until the dust settles and one (and hopefully only one) API comes out on top. Microsoft may have come “late” to the cloud computing table, but it’s certainly making up time by moving forward with its Dynamic Infrastructure Toolkit for System Center.

blockquote The Dynamic Infrastructure Toolkit for System Center is a free, partner-extensible toolkit that will enable datacenters to dynamically pool, allocate, and manage resources to enable IT as a service. Whether you’re an enterprise customer, a systems integrator, or an independent software vendor, the toolkit will help you create agile, virtualized IT infrastructures.

-- Microsoft Cloud Computing Infrastructure solutions

What’s a bit different about Microsoft’s Dynamic Infrastructure Toolkit for System Center (DIT-SC) is that it’s not focusing on standardizing the interface to the cloud, a la Yet Another Cloud API, but rather it’s focused inward, on operations, much in the same way the cloud API of Yahoo! is highly focused on internal rather than external operations.

  

Bill Zack reviews A Pragmatic Hybrid Approach to Cloud Computing white paper tin this 3/3/2010 post to the Innov8Showcase blog:

Click here to download the white paper

The paper on Cloud Computing that is referenced in this article (“Outlook: Partly Cloudy with Sunny Spells to Follow”) is one of the best treatments of the subject of Public, Private and Hybrid clouds that I have ever read.

It was written [for] and delivered at a Cloud Computing event in the UK.

“Last week over 120 came to the UK's most important cloud computing event. Attendees were eager to find out about the realities of cloud computing and how to get the most from this latest IT focus, and key contributors Microsoft and Dot Net Solutions presented a new white paper.
With constant pressure to manage IT costs, cloud solutions offer a new way to provide cost effective IT solutions, but without having to transfer all of your technology over to the cloud in one major leap.
Matt Deacon, Chief Architectural Advisor at Microsoft, and Dan Scarfe, CEO of Dot Net Solutions, outlined a pragmatic hybrid approach to cloud  computing. They outlined how customers can combine cloud solutions with their existing applications and infrastructure, to achieve IT cost savings, flexibility and the ability to bring new ideas to market rapidly and effectively.”

IM[NS]HO Everyone should read it.

Matthew Broersma’s Cray and Microsoft join forces on cloud datacentres post of 3/3/2010 reports:

Supercomputer maker Cray's custom engineering group has teamed up with Microsoft Research to look into lowering the costs of running cloud-computing datacentres.

The initiative will make use of the HPC specialist's intellectual property in system design, including high-density packaging, Cray said in its announcement on Tuesday. The partners will also work on efficient power delivery and cooling innovations, with the aim of reducing facility, power and hardware costs.

"The results of the project have the potential to deliver significant cost savings for operating a cloud-computing datacentre," said Cray vice president of custom engineering, Chuck Morreale, in a statement.

The alliance is the first step into the commercial market for Cray's custom engineering group, which was formed in 2008. The group builds special-purpose supercomputers for individual customers, applying Cray technologies such as the EcoPhlex liquid-cooling system and providing custom data-management and consulting systems. Last summer, Cray said the custom engineering division was growing more quickly than the rest of the company …

See the University of Washington’s Computer Science & Engineering School Microsoft’s Steve Ballmer at UW, Thursday March 4 post of 3/2/2010 in the Cloud Computing Events section.

Juniper Research reports More than 130 million Enterprise Users in the Mobile Cloud by 2014 in this 3/3/2010 post:

Juniper research, a Media Partner of the Cloud Computing Congress, reports on new mobile cloud computing findings.

As collaborative applications become ever more important for enterprise, a new report from Juniper Research has found that the number of enterprise customers using mobile cloud-based applications will rise to more than 130 million by 2014, facilitated by platform as a service (PaaS) deployments from key players such as Google and Microsoft.

The report found that the market for connected enterprise apps had benefitted from the success of Apple’s iPhone and App Store. It said that this was reflected both by a marked increase in both the number of enterprise apps available to end-users and also in the fact that such apps were themselves becoming far more attractive given the wide-ranging enhancements to smartphone user interfaces in the wake of the iPhone launch.

Furthermore, Juniper’s Mobile Cloud Applications research found that as cloud providers were increasingly opening up their APIs for application providers seeking to develop browser-based or thin client applications, this provided greater opportunity and incentive for developers seeking to reduce the costs associated by porting apps across multiple platforms.

According to report author Dr Windsor Holden, “A cloud-based ecosystem for enterprise apps will be attractive both for developers and enterprises alike. For developers, cloud opens up a far wider potential audience for their products; for enterprise customers, outsourcing application management to a remote third-party, costed on a scalable, pay-per-use basis, offers far more flexibility combined with a significant reduction in capital expenditure.” …

Alex Williams analyzes the Juniper cloud research in his How Many Enterprise Workers Will Work in the Mobile Cloud? Try 130 Million post of 3/3/2010:

200px-Cloud_computing.pngJuniper Research has come out with more analysis that shows just how big the mobile enterprise market will be for cloud computing.

According to Juniper, the advent of collaboration tools will mean that 130 million enterprise workers will use the mobile cloud by 2014.

The steep climb will be in part due to the Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS) offerings from companies like Google and Microsoft. [Emphasis added.]

The rise is already evident as more people adopt smartphones. In particular, Juniper points to the iPhone and the App store as catalysts for the growth. People are using their iPhones to use a variety of applications for the work they do.The report also cites the iPhone user interface and how it has spurred adoption and lead to a higher level of quality in smartphones across the wider market.

The report also cites how cloud computing providers have opened up their API's, which in turn has attracted waves of developers. The benefits to developer and customers are cited as reasons why we will see the surge. Developers can easily deploy applications to the cloud. And the greater variety of offerings drives a higher customer base.

Jay Fry recommends Going rogue, cloud computing-style: what you can learn by going around IT, as well as the San Francisco Cloud Computing Club in this 3/2/2010 post:

I have to say, the San Francisco Cloud [Computing] Club (#sfcloudclub on Twitter) is a great place to hear good ideas get batted around.

For the uninitiated, the group is a bunch of cloud computing experts, thinkers, and doers from around the Bay Area who occasionally give up an evening for a good discussion/argument or two about what’s happening in this market. (I wrote up one of the previous lively, cloud-filled conversations this group hosted in an earlier post: “Two cloud computing Rorschach tests: ‘legacy clouds’ and the lock-in lesson” for those who want to get a taste for the group’s content.)

As the group is getting ready for an expanded meeting of the minds connected with the upcoming Cloud Connect conference in Santa Clara (March 15-18), I realized that I’m still mulling over an idea or two about the psychology of cloud computing adoption brought up about the during the group’s MLK Day get-together in January.

Big companies will adopt cloud computing very conservatively, right?

Back at that meeting, we spent a bit of time on how companies are actually adopting cloud computing. The difficulty that big companies currently have with the public cloud has been covered extensively. It’s worrisome for them, thanks to things we’ve all heard about, like security, performance and reliability, and lock-in worries. At Cloud Club, we discussed how many orgs, as a result, are (officially, anyway) saying that they want to work on private clouds instead.

But most interestingly, we also discussed the truly amazing tendency that people in even in the most conservative IT organizations have to, well, “go rogue.”

In some of the most locked-down IT environments, folks try innovative stuff on their own, even when it doesn’t meet all of their strict requirements. Why? To help them get their job done in a much better or faster way. …

Jay continues with analysis of the benefits of “going rogue” with cloud computing.

Update 3/4/2010: Jay Fry’s Two cloud computing Rorschach tests: 'legacy clouds' and the lock-in lesson post of 11/11/2009 chronicles a November, 2009 San Francisco Cloud Computing Club meeting:

This week's San Francisco Cloud Computing Club gathering was a great place to meet some of the movers and shakers in the cloud computing market (or at least the ones within a short drive of San Francisco). The event's concept was to spend some quality time talking through cloud computing issues with a crowd of people who spend all day thinking about the cloud and working on making it a reality.

As James Urquhart (CNET blogger from Cisco) guided the conversation, I heard two interesting points of contention that divided the room pretty dramatically. It struck me that each comment could actually serve as a Rorschach test of a person's view of how powerful and important the concept of cloud computing actually is.

One question was about where IT has been; the other helps define where we might be able to go. Both say a lot about the approach to cloud computing that you're likely to take.

  1. Is cloud computing compelling enough to change how IT runs existing apps? …
  2. Has the industry learned its lesson about lock-in? …

So, my point in highlighting this subset of the Cloud Club conversations was this: keep an eye on these questions. They are some of more interesting things playing out in the cloud computing space.

And, for as much fun as it was to spend several hours in good-natured arguments over these and other topics in a penthouse in San Francisco, none of the answers will appear magically, nor overnight. We leave that to time, actual customers, and the market to decide.

David F. Carr asserts “Cloud computing sets some businesses free. But it also locks them in” in his Happily Locked Into The Cloud article o f3/2/2010 for Forbes Magazine:

As CEO of Vetrazzo, a Richmond, Calif., firm that makes chic high-end building materials out of recycled glass, James Sheppard has embraced cloud computing. The applications he uses to run his business are accessed--and even programmed and designed--over the Internet.

Vetrazzo built a custom application that makes use of the servers and software provided by Salesforce.com. These programs provide many of the services familiar to the thousands of other Salesforce.com ( CRM - news - people ) customers. But Vetrazzo went beyond customization of what Salesforce.com provides. Instead of purchasing an enterprise resource planning system from an SAP ( SAP - news - people ) or an Oracle, Vetrazzo essentially created its own, built with Salesforce.com's programming tools.

Sheppard, a former enterprise software salesman, began running his business on the application a year ago and says it has set him free. The system administrators at Salesforce.com are the ones who have to worry about most of the technical details of keeping the system reliable, secure and available.

But that freedom has come with a trade-off, in the form of vendor lock-in. Sheppard's core business application is running on a proprietary platform created by Salesforce.com and available only to its customers. That means, for example, that Sheppard would not be able to transfer his application to another data center. …

David continues with his analysis of the cloud’s vendor lock-in threat.

Joe Weinman promises "At the upcoming Cloud Connect conference, we will evaluate a variety of scenarios that determine where and when the move to cloud computing makes financial sense” in his Time To Do The Math On Cloud Computing article of 3/2/2010 for InformationWeek:

In two weeks, I'll be in Santa Clara at the industry's newest event, Cloud Connect. I'm chairing a track focused on Cloudonomics, a term I coined a couple of years ago to connote the complex economics of using cloud infrastructure, platform, and software services. There are a number of great technical tracks planned, but mine is focused on what I consider to be the most important question: "Why do cloud?"

This is the question that any business-focused CIO must ask. After all, CIO's have a small number of projects that they can really focus on in any given year, and major initiatives must have a compelling rationale or won't get supported by senior leadership, including the board. The technology will only be important if the business value is clear and compelling.

The head of security company McAfee gives his views on the state of IT security today.

In practice, there are a number of reasons to leverage the cloud. One is agility: Resources and services that are immediately available for on-demand use clearly enhance agility over months-long engineering, procurement, and installation efforts. This can help to introduce new services, test new code, enter new markets, or meet unexpected sales spikes. Another is user experience. Larger cloud providers' globally dispersed footprint can bring highly interactive processing closer to the end user.

But perhaps topping the list is total cost reduction. According to a recent Yankee Group report, 43% of enterprises cite cost control as a rationale for interest in the cloud. So, how exactly should we think about cloud costs? That's the topic of my track. …

Phil Wainwright makes the case for private clouds in his Cloud, it’s a web thing post of 3/2/2010 to the Enterprise Irregulars blog, which replies to Randy Bias’ Debunking the “No Such Thing as a Private Cloud” Myth essay:

Having read (hat-tip Dennis Howlett) Randy Bias’ article at Kendallsquare on Debunking the “No Such Thing as a Private Cloud” Myth I have to say — rather like the apocryphal Irish direction-giver — if I’d wanted to make a case for private cloud, I wouldn’t have started from there. Randy and I joined a civilized conversation a few weeks back as a follow-up to my earlier post on this topic, and I fear he’s already forgotten every dam’ thing I said. So I guess I’ll have to reiterate it.

But first, let me (shock, horror!) make the case, such as it is, for private cloud. It looks like we’re stuck with the term, along with all the ugly implementations that are going to be classed under it and which I fear will ultimately lead to its becoming discredited — unfairly dragging the reputation of true cloud computing through the same mud as it does so. As you can see, I still distrust the term, mainly because it is so open to misinterpretation, and I shan’t be using it myself without heavy qualification and many caveats — which, by the way, should make for an interesting panel discussion with Verizon, IBM and others that I’ll be moderating at the All About Cloud event in San Francisco this May [see disclosure]. But I do see circumstances where it’s possible to make a case for implementing cloud-like infrastructure in a private environment, and Randy, despite starting his exposition from completely the wrong starting point, does end up making a statement about private cloud with which I can heartily agree:

“The private cloud model is a critical transitional step. It is an essential component to help larger organizations move their compute capacity to the public cloud.” …

You can read the complete article @ Software as Services.

Mark Little’s Cloud as the death of middleware? post of 2/13/2010 is an essay, which begins:

Over the last few months I've been hearing and reading people suggesting that the Cloud ([fill in your own definition]) is either the death of middleware, or the death of "traditional" middleware. What this tells me is that those individuals don't understand the concepts behind middleware ("traditional" or not). In some ways that's not too hard to understand given the relatively loose way in which we use the term 'middleware'. Often within the industry middleware is something we all understand when we're talking about it, but it's not something that we tend to be able to identify clearly: what one person considers application may be another's middleware component. In my world, middleware is basically anything that exists above the operating system and below the application (I think the fact that these days we tend to ignore the old ISO 7 Layer stack is a real shame because that can only help such a definition.) …

He concludes:

Of course there'll be new things that we'll need to add to the infrastructure for supporting Cloud applications, just as JEE doesn't match CORBA exactly, or CORBA doesn't match DCE etc. There may be new frameworks and languages involved too. But this new Cloud wave (hmmm, mixing metaphors there I think) needs to build on what we've learned and developed rather than being an excuse to reimplement or remake the software world in "our" own image. That would be far too costly in time and effort, and I have yet to be convinced that it would result in anything substantially better than the alternative approach. If I were to try to sum up what I'm saying here it would be: Evolution Rather Than Revolution!

Mark is the CTO for JBoss at Red Hat.

<Return to section navigation list> 

Cloud Security and Governance

Dana Gardner writes “Cloud Security Alliance defines top threats to secure cloud computing” as a lead-in to his Cloud Computing Services Are the Next Generation of IT Briefings Direct post of 3/3/2010:

It's one of the major issues that keeps cloud computing from working its way deeper and more quickly into the enterprise IT mainstream.
But what are the potential threats around using cloud services? How can companies make sure business processes and data remain secured in the cloud? And how can CIOs accurately assess the risks and benefits of cloud adoption strategies?

Hewlett-Packard (HP) and the Cloud Security Alliance (CSA) answer these and other questions in a new research report entitled, "Top Threats to Cloud Computing Report."

The report, which was highlighted during the Cloud Security Summit at the RSA conference this week, taps the knowledge of information security experts at 29 enterprises, solutions providers and consulting firms that deal with demanding and complex cloud environments. [Disclosure: HP is a sponsor of BriefingsDirect podcasts.] …

Dana concludes:

I'll be moderating a panel in San Francisco in conjunction with RSA later this week on the very subject of cloud security with Jeremiah Grossman, founder and Chief Technology Officer of WhiteHat Security; Chris Hoff, Director of Cloud & Virtualization Solutions at Cisco Systems and a Founding Member of the CSA, and Andy Ellis, Chief Security Architect at Akamai Technologies.

We'll be rebroadcasting the panel "live" with call-in for questions and answer at noon ET on March 31. More details to come.

Alex Williams reports Cloud Computing Security: What The Big Guns Have In Store in this 3/2/2010 post from the RSA 2010 conference to the ReadWriteCloud blog:

The RSA Conference is the event for news to spill over with talk about cloud computing security.

Let's take a look at some of the announcements from the major players in the market, including Intel, Novell and Cisco.

Intel, RSA, VMware and the Trusted Server

According to Dark Reading, the companies demonstrated a proof-of-concept for "building security into the cloud computing infrastructure."

The companies are playing on the white listing concept, which has gained wider acceptance in the security world. The idea being that if a server is trusted or white listed then it will be far less vulnerable to malware attacks …

Novell and the Cloud Security Alliance

Novell is teaming up with the Cloud Security Alliance to push standards for cloud computing. The effort is called the "Trusted Cloud Initiative." According to Information Week, Novel will develop standards for cloud security, compliance, identity management and other related issues.

Cloud computing is essentially a world with no standards whatsoever. Everyone has different meanings for the fundamental aspects that are a part of cloud computing. That leaves the customer with little way to fully understand what they are committing to with a cloud vendor.

In its second year, The Cloud Security Alliance consists of technology companies seeking to develop use cases about the processes and practices around cloud computing security.

Cisco: Developing Mobile Phone Security

Cisco is developing an "always on" security system for mobile devices. According to Computerworld, the service would give enterprise managers the ability to control cloud-based applications on an employee's mobile device.

See Warwick Ashford’s RSA 2010: identity management key to cloud security, says Microsoft’s Scott Charney post of 3/3/2010 in the AppFabric: Access Control and Service Bus section.

Jon Oltsik claims “Cisco, EMC, Intel and VMware are all over cloud security'” in his RSA 2010: Cloud security announcements dominate already post of 3/2/2010 to NetworkWorld’s Back to Cisco Subnet:

It's pouring in San Francisco but ironically the RSA Conference is already pointed toward clouds -- in this case cloud computing security.

There were two announcements yesterday around securing private clouds. New initiative king Cisco announced its "Secure Borderless Network Architecture," which is actually pretty interesting. Cisco wants to unite applications and mobile devices through an "always-on" VPN. In other words, Cisco software will enforce security policies for mobile devices about which applications they can use and when -- without user intervention. Pretty cool but you would need a whole bunch of new Cisco stuff to make this happen.

On another front, industry big-wigs EMC, Intel, and VMware are pushing for a "hardware root of trust" for cloud computing. The goal here is to create technology that lets cloud providers share system state, event, and configuration data with customers in real-time. In this way, customers can integrate cloud security with their own security operations processes and management. This is extremely important for regulatory compliance. (Note: Another reason why EMC/RSA bought Archer Technologies).

These interesting announcement probably presage a 2010 RSA Conferernce trend -- "all cloud all of the time." Since ESG Research indicates that only 12% of midsized (i.e. less than 1,000 employees) and enterprise (i.e. more than 1,000 employees) will prioritize cloud spending in 2010, all of this cloud yackety yack may be a bit over the top.

Two other announcement worth noting here:

1. An actual leading voice on cloud computing security the Cloud Security Alliance (CSA) teamed up with IEEE to survey users about cloud computing security. Users overwhelmingly want to see industry standards and soon. Bravo CSA and IEEE, I couldn't agree more.

2. I like the F5 Networks/Infoblox announcement around DNSSEC. The two companies will offer integration technology between F5 load balancers and Infoblox DNSSEC. This partnership blends the security of DNSSEC with the reality of distributed web-based apps and infrastructure. Kudos to the companies, the Federal government will be especially pleased.

Jon also finds “Lots of cloud hype -- a little bit of real wisdom” at RSA as he reports in RSA Day #1: A Whirlwind of Activity post to NetWorld World of 3/3/2010:

I'm in San Francisco at the RSA Conference, 2010. Attendance is up over last year's recession version of the show and a more up-beat vibe all around.

Of course, the smell of industry hype is also in the air in the form of cloud computing. RSA's Art Coviello (amongst others), crowed about how the cloud was the ultimately destiny of Internet computing. Cisco announced an "always-on" cloud computing VPN. EMC, Intel, and VMware want "roots of trust" for cloud hardware.

The good news is that we are talking about security as we develop cloud security so in theory, security may be "baked" into the cloud. The bad news is that we are talking about future and extremely hyped technology when we have serious security problems today. Will talking about Cloud Computing circa 2012 address today's cybercrime problems? The industry needs to focus on addressing today's threats or cloud computing will never arrive.

On a more positive note, Microsoft's Scott Charney stole the show yesterday. Unlike other speakers, Scott was more pragmatic by addressing things like quarentining infected PCs, government cybersecurity responsibilities and tactics, and public-private partnerships. Charney did mention cloud by declaring that identity and privacy are critical for cloud security (I wholeheartedly agree) and then announced that Microsoft has developed a new identity software framework called U-Prove and that it will be offering the code as open source for all to examine it and build upon it. Kudos to Charney and Microsoft to introducing real action into the marketing buzz. …

<Return to section navigation list> 

Cloud Computing Events

The University of Washington’s Computer Science & Engineering School reports in their Microsoft’s Steve Ballmer at UW, Thursday March 4 post of 3/2/2010:

Steve Ballmer, Microsoft CEO, will discuss what’s ahead for computing, with a particular focus on how cloud computing will change the way people and businesses use technology. The event will take place on Thursday March 4 at 10 a.m. in the Microsoft Atrium of the Paul G. Allen Center for Computer Science & Engineering. Plentiful open seating and standing room will be available. Please join us for what’s sure to be an interesting talk about the world of tech.

A portable Microsoft datacenter, housed in a cargo container, will be available for tours all day long. Microsoft’s IT Pre-Assembled-Component (ITPAC) is one example of the company’s strategy to modularize the entire datacenter. During the tour, learn about the design decisions and functionality that will power the next generation of technology.

See Microsoft information on the talk, plus webcast information, here.  Dan Reed blog post here.  Microsoft “Azure cloud science” TechFest web page, including a UW oceanography collaboration, here.  TechFlash post here.

Maps and directions here.  UW webcast information here.  Web-archived videos of the event will be linked here and from the Microsoft site.

The Microsoft press release is Microsoft on Cloud Computing.

Abhishek Baxi’s March Architect Innovation Cafe Webcasts post of 3/3/2010 announced a Windows Azure Design Patterns Webcast on 3/26/2010 at 10:00 AM PST:

Abstract: One of the challenges in adopting a new platform is finding usable design patterns that work for developing effective solutions. The Catch-22 is that design patterns are discovered and not invented. Nevertheless it is important to have some guidance on what design patterns make sense early in the game.

This webcast attacks the problem through a set of application scenario contexts, Azure features and solution examples. It is unique in its approach and the fact that it includes the use of features from all components of the Windows Azure Platform including the Windows Azure OS, Windows Azure AppFabric and SQL Azure. In this webcast you will learn about the components of the Windows Azure Platform that can be used to solve specific business problems.

Register here.

Geva Perrry will moderate an Open APIs Panel at OSBC, according to this 3/1/2010 post:

I was kindly invited by Matt Asay to moderate a panel at the Open Source Business Conference (OSBC) on March 18 at San Francisco. Below are the details of the panel.

I did not write the description below (it was already there when I got on board), but I think it makes some interesting points. That said, I'd love to get any comments, suggestions, ideas on what you think the panel should be talking about. What's your take on the topic and what do you think are the interesting drivers and barriers for open API adoption -- and how do open APIs affect cloud computing and business in general.

Please share your thoughts in the comments.

Open Cloud – Open APIs and Economic Growth

Moderator: Geva Perry

Panelists:

Scott Metzger, CTO, TransUnion
Dion Hinchcliffe, CTO, Hinchcliffe & Company
Peter Coffee, Director Platform Research, Salesforce.com
Mike Olson, CEO, Cloudera
Sam Ramji, VP Strategy, Sonoa

Openness has been used as an index of economic growth in international markets. With the rapid expansion of cloud computing, we have seen a wave of business expansion based on open APIs which has enabled innovation by 3rd parties, much as open source has enabled this trend in software. Openness is unevenly distributed however, and in some areas open APIs do not promise open data, which threatens the expansion of the cloud economy. What are the key concerns for technologists in the openness of cloud computing? How can we collectively drive the standards of the industry towards an open cloud? Come to this session to learn about the state of the art and challenge the panelists on the value and requirements of openness in the cloud.

<Return to section navigation list> 

Other Cloud Computing Platforms and Services

Mikael Ricknäs claims Amazon Web Services CTO out to Prove Enterprise Chops in a 3/2/2010 article for PC World:

There is still a misconception that Amazon Web Services exists to sell the company's excess server capacity, but that is not the case, CTO Werner Vogels said during a keynote at Cebit.

"There is a myth out there that when Christmas comes, suddenly, all of the foundations under your building will be gone ... that is obviously not the case," said Vogels, referring to Amazon's high-volume sales during the holidays.

During his speech, he showcased the customers that are using Amazon Web Services, with the aim of persuading skeptics that his company offers a viable option.

For example, also at Cebit Software AG announced ARISalign, which offers business process management as a service using Amazon Web services' cloud computing. Time-to-market and tight control over costs were among the reasons Software AG picked Amazon, Vogels said.

Also, the growth of Amazon's cloud can be seen in the number of objects stored on S3 (Simple Storage Service). The number grew from 54 billion at this time last year to more than 100 billion, according to Vogels.

Bigger scale lets Amazon Web Services offer lower prices than competitors, according to Vogels. The latest price cut was Feb. 1 for outbound data transfer. …

<Return to section navigation list> 

February 2010 Uptime Reports for OakLeaf Azure Test Harness Running in the South Central US Data Center

For the first time, Mon.itor.us reported 100% uptime for the live OakLeaf Systems Azure Table Services Sample Project during an entire month, albeit a short month. Following are the four weekly reports for February 2010:

MonitorUsFebruary2010-583px 

Again, Pingdom reported more downtime (00:04:19) than Mon.itor.us (00:00:00):

Pingdom02-2010-589px

The difference could be explained by Pingdom testing at a higher frequency than Mon.itor.us.

Following is the usage charge report, which reports Compute Hours and Storage Transactions. The amounts are included as a result of my MSDN Premium subscription. (Click image for full-size screen capture.)

WindowsAzureUsageCharges02-2010-640px

Following are links to the three previous uptime reports:

  1. November 2009 Uptime Reports for OakLeaf Azure Demos Running in the South Central US Data Center
  2. December 2009 Uptime Reports for OakLeaf Azure Demos Running in the South Central US Data Center
  3. January 2010 Uptime Reports for OakLeaf Azure Test Harness Running in the South Central US Data Center

Tuesday, March 02, 2010

Windows Azure and Cloud Computing Posts for 3/1/2010+

Windows Azure, SQL Azure Database and related cloud computing topics now appear in this weekly series.

 
Update 3/4/2010: Added link to Jan Algermissens’ "Classification of HTTP-based APIs" study to the Azure Blob, Table and Queue Services section at the suggestion of Mike Amundsen (see his comment to this post.)

Note: This post is updated daily or more frequently, depending on the availability of new articles in the following sections:

To use the above links, first click the post’s title to display the single article you want to navigate.

Cloud Computing with the Windows Azure Platform published 9/21/2009. Order today from Amazon or Barnes & Noble (in stock.)

Read the detailed TOC here (PDF) and download the sample code here.

Discuss the book on its WROX P2P Forum.

See a short-form TOC, get links to live Azure sample projects, and read a detailed TOC of electronic-only chapters 12 and 13 here.

Wrox’s Web site manager posted on 9/29/2009 a lengthy excerpt from Chapter 4, “Scaling Azure Table and Blob Storage” here.

You can now download and save the following two online-only chapters in Microsoft Office Word 2003 *.doc format by FTP:

  • Chapter 12: “Managing SQL Azure Accounts and Databases”
  • Chapter 13: “Exploiting SQL Azure Database's Relational Features”

HTTP downloads of the two chapters are available from the book's Code Download page; these chapters will be updated for the January 4, 2010 commercial release in February 2010. 

Azure Blob, Table and Queue Services

Lori MacVittie claims REST API Developers Between a Rock and a Hard Place in this 3/2/2010 post:

Coffee Mug - Far Side Damned if You Do Dont A recent blog on EBPML.ORG entitled “REST 2010 - Where are We?” very aggressively stated: “REST is just a "NO WS-*" movement.” The arguments presented are definitely interesting but the most compelling point made is in the way that REST APIs are constructed, namely that unlike the “ideal” REST API described where HTTP methods are used to define action (verb) and the path the resource (noun), practical implementations of REST are using a strange combination of both actions (verbs) and resources (nouns) in URIs.

What this does is simulate very closely SOA services, in which the endpoint is a service (resource) upon which an action (method) is invoked. In the case of SOAP the action is declared either in the HTTP header (old skool SOAPaction) or as part of the SOAP payload. So the argument that most REST APIs, in practice, are really little more than a NO WS-* API is fairly accurate.

In “REST != HTTP “ Ted Neward very convincingly argues that the problem isn’t that most “REST” APIs aren’t REST (based on the definition and constraints set down by Fielding in the first place) but that folks are calling them REST despite the fact that they aren’t. That’s not necessarily the developer’s fault and, in the cases pointed out it’s quite possible that the decision to call the API a RESTful API was made by someone other than the developer.

The fact is that there are artificial environmental constraints that force RESTful developers into diverging from the “one true REST path” that leads to a more services-based and less structured implementation than perhaps many would like. …

Lori continues with an analysis of “problems developers face” when attempting to adhere to strict REST standards and concludes:

… The solution is, ultimately, just to not call such APIs REST. Nor RESTful, nor even REST-like. In the same way that we shouldn’t be calling every web-based application “cloud computing” we shouldn’t be calling APIs “REST” when they really aren’t. The argument that what we’re calling today “REST APIs” are really “NO WS-* APIs” is fairly accurate. But to call them simply “web services” would certainly confuse them with their SOAPy counterparts and cause the other side of the fence to rebel just as fiercely.

So until someone comes up with a better name that sticks, we may have to fall back on the tried and true “formerly known as” formula. I propose the “Formerly Unintentionally Counterfactually Known as REST” API.

It still has REST in the name, so marketing should be happy with that, right?

Update 3/4/2010: Jan Algermissens’ Classification of HTTP-based APIs study offers a pair of tables that document REST interface constraints:

Classifies HTTP-based APIs. “The classification achieves an explicit differentiation between the various kinds of uses of HTTP and provides a foundation to analyse and describe the system properties induced.”

Describes the “effect of removing a certain interface constraint the following table provides an overview of the impact upon selected system properties. Removing constraints can reduce start-up cost which in some scenarios might be of more concern than long-term maintenace- or evolution cost. The right hand side columns of the table place the impact of removing constraints into an overall context of start up-, maintenance- and evolution cost.”

Thanks to Mike Amundsen for the pointer (see comments to this post).

William Vambenepe asserts Two versions of a protocol is one too many in this 3/1/2010 post:

There is always a temptation, when facing a hard design decision in the process of creating an interface or a protocol, to produce two (or more) versions. It’s sometimes a good idea, as a way to explore where each one takes you so you can make a more informed choice. But we know how this invariably ends up. Documents get published that arguably should not. It’s even harder in a standard working group, where someone was asked (or at least encouraged) by the group to create each of the alternative specifications. Canning one is at best socially awkward (despite the appearances, not everyone in standards is a psychopath or a sadist) and often politically impossible.

And yet, it has to be done. Compare the alternatives, then pick one and commit. Don’t confuse being accommodating with being weak.

The typical example these days is of course SOAP versus REST: the temptation is to support both rather than make a choice. This applies to standards and to proprietary interfaces. When a standard does this, it hurts rather than promote interoperability. Vendors have a bit more of an excuse when they offer a choice (“the customer is always right”) but in reality it forces customers to play Russian roulette whether they want it or not. Because one of the alternatives will eventually be left behind (either discarded or maintained but not improved). If you balance the small immediate customer benefit of using the interface style they are most used to with the risk of redoing the integration down the road, the value proposition of offering several options crumbles.

Pedantic disclaimer: I use the term "REST" in this post the way it is often (incorrectly) used, to mean pretty much anything that uses HTTP without a SOAP wrapper. The technical issues are a topic for other posts.]

CMDBf

CMDBf [Configuration Management Database Federation] v1 is a DMTF [Distributed Management Task Force] standard. It is a SOAP-based protocol. For v2, it has been suggested that there should a REST version. I don’t know what the CMDBf group (in which I participate) will end up doing but I’ve made my position clear: I could go either way (remain with SOAP or dump it) but I do not want to have two versions of the protocol (one SOAP one REST). If we think we’re better off with a REST version, then let’s make v2 REST-only. Supporting both mechanisms in v2 would be stupid. They would address the same use cases and only serve to provide political ass-coverage. There is no functional need for both. The argument that we need to keep supporting SOAP for the benefit of those who implemented v1 doesn’t fly. As an implementer, nobody is saying that you need to turn off your v1 services the second you launch the v2 version. …

William continues with arguments against dual REST and SOAP API implementations, including Amazon’s S3 API.

<Return to section navigation list> 

SQL Azure Database (SADB, formerly SDS and SSDS)

Guy Barrette asks SQL Azure – is master billable? in this 3/2/2010 post:

In SQL Azure, when you create a “server”, a master database is automatically created and you’ll see it listed in the databases list.  Here’s a screenshot after I created a new database called Test.

AzureSQLDatabases

I was surprised that master is listed like a standard 1GB database and I feared that it might be billable.  I could not find any information so this morning, after a day of usage, I went into my billings.

AzureSQLDatabasesBilling

Looks like only my Test database was counted as billable.

I came to the same conclusion when I checked over a longer duration, as noted in my Determining Your Azure Services Platform Usage Charges post of 2/11/2010.

Guy is a Microsoft Regional Director for Montreal, Canada.

<Return to section navigation list> 

AppFabric: Access Control, Service Bus and Workflow

Vittorio Bertocci announces on 3/2/2010 Microsoft’s U-Prove Community Technical Preview release at the RSA Converence:

Conventional wisdom suggests that if you want to increase security, you need to sacrifice some privacy: if you took a flight in the last decade you know exactly what I mean. We are so used to that tradeoff that you consider it one of the many Heisenberg principles governing computer science.

But what if this status quo could be broken? What if you could have security AND privacy?

Enter the U-Prove technology, a groundbreaking innovation that allows you to do just that. Introduced by cryptographer Dr. Stefan Brands in 2004, it took the industry by storm (1,  2). In 2008 Microsoft acquired the technology and hired Stefan & his crew (Christian Paquin, Greg Thompson) in the identity and access division. They have been busy ever since to integrate U-Prove in the Identity Metasystem: today we can finally let the world give a first glance to their work.

Today, March 2, 2010, at the RSA Security Conference, Microsoft is taking a first step to make the U-Prove technology available to the public and interested parties:

  • First, we are opening up the U-Prove intellectual property with a cryptographic specification under the Microsoft Open Specification Promise (OSP).  Two open source software toolkits are being made available-- C# and Java editions-- so the broadest audience of commercial and open source software developers can access the technology.
  • Second, we are releasing a public Community Technology Preview (CTP), which integrates the U-Prove technology with the Microsoft identity platform technologies (Active Directory Federation Services 2.0, Windows Identity Foundation, and Windows CardSpace v2). A second specification (under the OSP) is available for integrating U-Prove into open source identity selectors.

As it is customary by now, the IdElement is providing extensive coverage of the U-Prove CTP [with these Channel9 videos]:

<Return to section navigation list>

Live Windows Azure Apps, APIs, Tools and Test Harnesses

Eric Nelson shares links for Getting PhP and Ruby working on Windows Azure and SQL Azure in this 3/2/2010 post:

When Windows Azure was first released in 2008 the only programming languages you could use were .NET languages such as Visual Basic and C# and the applications you built had to run in Partial Trust (Similar to ASP.NET Medium Trust).

In the interim we have made a number of changes including allowing applications to run in full trust, native code is now supported (no longer had to be managed code such as C#) and we support FastCGI applications. Which means:

  • Windows Azure supports the Internet Information Server (IIS) 7.0 FastCGI module, so that you can host web roles that require an interpreter, or that are written in native code.
  • You can host web roles and worker roles written in managed code under Windows Azure full trust. A role running under full trust can call .NET libraries requiring full trust, read the local server registry, and call native code libraries.
  • You can develop a service in native code and test and publish this service to Windows Azure. A role running native code can interact with the Windows Azure runtime by calling functions in the Microsoft Service Hosting Runtime Library.

As a result it is now possible to build applications for Windows Azure using languages such as Java, PhP and Ruby.  A couple of UK examples have popped up in the last few days.

PhP on Windows Azure: Last Saturday at the Open Space Coding Day on Azure,  Martin Beeby and another developer sat down to get PhP running on Azure. It turned out to be surprisingly straightforward to do.

Ruby on Rails on Windows Azure and SQL Azure: Last week Nick Hill in Microsoft UK Consulting Services posted on getting Ruby on Rails running on Azure after a customer engagement.

Related Links

The Windows Azure Team announced Updated Release of Windows Azure Service Management Cmdlets Now Available on 3/1/2010:

An updated release of the Windows Azure Service Management (WASM) Cmdlets for PowerShell is now available. These cmdlets enable developers to effectively automate and manage all services in Windows Azure such as:

  • Deploy new Hosted Services
  • Upgrade your Services
  • Remove your Hosted Services
  • Manage your Storage accounts
  • Manage your Certificates
  • Configure your Diagnostics
  • Transfer your Diagnostics Information

Built to meet the demand for an automation API that would fit into the standard toolset for IT professionals and based on PowerShell so they can also be used as the basis for very complicated deployment and automation scripts, these cmdlets make it simple to script out deployments, upgrades, and scaling of Windows Azure applications as well as set and manage diagnostics configurations.

To learn more about these cmdlets, as well as see a few examples of how to use them for a variety of common tasks, read the blog post, "WASM Cmdlets Updated" by Ryan Dunn, technical evangelist for Windows Azure. You can also find more examples and documentation on these cmdlets by typing ‘Get-Help <cmdlet> -full' from the PowerShell cmd prompt.

Every call to the Service Management API requires an X509 certificate and subscription ID for the account.  To get started, you will need to upload a valid certificate to the portal and have it installed locally to your workstation.  If you are unfamiliar with how to do this, you can follow the procedure outlined in "Exercise 2 - Using PowerShell to Manage Windows Azure Applications" on the Windows Azure Channel9 Learning Center.

Simon Davies answers the How does IP address allocation work for Compute Services in Windows Azure? question in this 3/1/2010 post:

Recently I have seen a lot of questions asking how Windows Azure allocates IP addresses to services. At this time Windows Azure does not offer the capability to fix an IP address for your service  however there are some scenarios where this can be a requirement, e.g. some external services require IP addresses of the caller to be pre-configured before allowing traffic to flow (SQL Azure does this) . The information in this post is designed to help you understand  how IP addresses are allocated in Windows  Azure and what you can do to ensure that they do not change.

Each compute service that is created in windows Azure has two deployment slots, one for production and one for staging, each of these slots has a DNS name and associated IP address. The DNS name associated with the production slot is assigned at the time that the service is created and is fixed for the lifetime of that service, the DNS name for the staging slot is dynamically generated each time a service is deployed.

Each  time a service instance is deployed to one of these slots the DNS name associated with it has an IP address assigned to it from a pool of available addresses. The service slot will then keep that IP address until  the service deployment is deleted. Upgrading your application, altering the configuration or swapping the production and staging slots will not cause the IP address to change.

The same IP address is used for both inbound and outbound traffic.

“Soma” Somasegar’s New Offers for Visual Studio 2010 post of 3/1/2010 describes new free Azure benefits with VS 2010 purchases:

… Today, we’re also unveiling an offer for customers who purchase Visual Studio Professional at retail. To help these developers fully realize the power and benefits of a MSDN subscription, I am announcing MSDN Essentials, a one-year trial MSDN subscription that will be included with every retail copy of Visual Studio Professional sold.

MSDN Essentials subscribers will have access to three of the latest Microsoft platforms: Windows 7 Ultimate, Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise, and SQL Server 2008 Datacenter R2 for development and test use, as well as 20 hours of Windows Azure.  Subscribers will also have access to MSDN’s Online Concierge, Priority Support in MSDN Forums, and will be included in special offers from partners. …

If that “20 hours of Windows Azure” is a one-time only event, big deal (worth $2.40). 20 hours per month (or week) for a year would be a more impressive offer, but still not enough to take the bite out of an individual developers budget for running a full-time Azure site.

Microsoft’s new, Web-based Microsoft Case Studies search tool turns up 67 case studies when using the search term “Azure” on 3/2/2010.

DotNetSolutions explains Windows Azure Diagnostics – Why the Trace.WriteLine method only sends Verbose messages in this 2/26/2010 post:

Logging diagnostic information plays a key part for any application. The .Net framework provides a number of Diagnostic features, which can be used to provide logging functionality in your application.

However, in Windows Azure, the diagnostic API available in early CTPs was very limited. In the November release of Windows Azure, a new feature for  Windows Azure Diagnostics was launched. I will not delve into details of how to use the Azure diagnostic API. You can read about this here and also here.

In this article, I will be focusing only on a recent challenge we came across while implementing the Windows Azure Diagnostics API for ScrumWall (http://scrumwall.cloudapp.net). ScrumWall uses a factory pattern to determine which concrete log writer to use. It had both a trace listener logger and a custom Windows Azure Table storage logger. The trace listeners implementation could be configured in web.config.

Return to section navigation list> 

Windows Azure Infrastructure

Bill Claybrook continues the public-versus-private cloud battle with his Cloud vs. in-house: Where to run that app? article of 3/1/2010 for ComputerWorld. Prefaced by “Options include public clouds and external private clouds. Here's how to choose wisely,” the article continues:

One of the biggest decisions IT managers have to make is how and where to run data center applications. Fortunately, there are multiple choices that lower costs and increase business agility, including server virtualization, internal clouds, public clouds and external private clouds.

Many IT organizations are taking advantage of these options. Server virtualization is currently being used by more than 70% of enterprises to reduce costs, and cloud computing is being used or planned for use by more than 10% of corporations, according to Antonio Piraino, research director at Tier1 Research.

It can be confusing and difficult to determine which cloud environment to use (see sidebar below for descriptions of the most popular types of clouds). There are few, if any, guidelines, and each company will almost certainly have a unique discussion about its choices because each will have varying requirements and different views of what cloud computing means.

To take advantage of the new opportunities afforded by cloud computing, IT organizations have to learn the differences between server virtualization and various types of clouds, and understand the risks associated with using each execution environment in terms of the characteristics of various applications. …

Bill Zack reviews Hanu Kommalapati’s Azure Platform for Enterprises article for MSDN Magazine’s March 2010 issue in a brief 3/1/2010 post to the Innovation Showcase blog:

This MSDN magazine article focuses on the use of Windows Azure in the Enterprise. Starting with the architecture of a cloud application in general and the Windows Azure Platform in particular. 

image

First the author reviews the (somewhat) accepted cloud taxonomy terms such as Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS),  Platform as a Service (PaaS) and Software + Services (S+S).

Then he puts the Windows Azure Platform into context as a powerful PaaS offering that is heading towards adding IaaS Features. 

Following that he goes on to show how it also interfaces nicely with a customer’s on premise Windows Server Platform infrastructure in a hybrid Software Plus Services model. Read more here.

Eugenio Pace’s SLA Quiz post of 3/1/2010 demonstrates how to calculate the uptime of “two-and-a-half nines” and other fractional SLAs:

A few days ago I met with Steve Marx, of Azure fame, and he mentioned how people often misunderstand SLAs percentages. So I posted this quiz on twitter:

image

The answer is: 99.99864% (or close)

Why?

  • One 9 = 99.9% = 100 – 1/10 = 1 – 1/(10^1)
  • Two 9’s = 99.99% = 100 – 1/100 = 1 – 1/(10^2)
  • Three 9’s = 99.999% = 100 – 1/1000 = 1 – 1/(10^3)

So, [t]wo and half 9’s = 100 – 1/(10^2.5) = 99.99684%

Daz Wilkins gets an “approved” :-)

Lori MacVittie’s asserts “Ultimately a highly-scalable, high-performance architecture will rely on choosing the right form factor in the right places at the right time” as a preface to her Square Infrastructure Pegs Don’t Fit in Round Network Holes post of 3/1/2010:

Garnaat's Theorem Scale is not just about servers, and for corporate data centers and cloud computing providers looking to realize the benefits of rapid elasticity and on-demand provisioning scale simply must be one of the foundational premises upon which a dynamic data center is built. And that includes the infrastructure.

This isn’t the first time I’ve touched upon this subject, but it’s a concept that needs to be reiterated – especially with so many pundits and analysts looking for the next big virtualization wave to crash onto the infrastructure beachhead. I’m here to tell you, though, that the devil is in the details. Virtual network appliances (VNAs) are certainly one means to achieving elastic scalability of infrastructure services but just as scale is not just about servers it’s also not just about form factor. It’s about the right form factor in the right place and, ultimately, at the right time.

First consider the scalability needs of aggregation points within an architecture. These are points at which high volumes of requests/traffic are essentially directed at one infrastructure solution, i.e. a Load balancer for application traffic, a router for network traffic. At these points in your architecture it would almost certainly be a bad idea to introduce a virtual network appliance because such solutions are much more constrained in terms of capacity than their hardware counterparts. This is due to inherent limitations on the virtualization platform, the network interfaces, and the operating system (if it is in the mix).

Where a single hardware load balancer can sustain millions of TCP connections, a virtual version of the same solution will unlikely be able to reach half of that image_thumb[20]capacity. The differences between hardware and software solutions are minimal, but among those differences are the way in which the different implementations interact with the network and available bandwidth. As we discussed in another post on a similar subject, scalability also becomes problematic because deploying multiple, cloned instances of any solution as a means to achieve higher capacity limits requires the use of virtualization, a la load balancing.

These high-volume, high-capacity strategic points of control are simply not good candidates for virtualization as a means to achieve scalability. There are two options for scaling these hardware solutions – use an extensible chassis based solution that can accommodate expansion of capacity through acquisition of additional “blades” or take advantage of the fact that most are equipped with specialized “clustering” that allows multiple devices to work in parallel while still ensuring reliability through fault-tolerance mechanisms. …

<Return to section navigation list> 

Cloud Security and Governance

Jonathan Penn covers RSA president, Art Coviello’s keynote address in Live at the RSA Conference: an industry view of 3/2/2010:

Just saw the keynote by Art Coviello, President, RSA. The focus was on securing the cloud. His main points were:

  1. Migration of IT to the cloud is inevitable. I totally agree with this, and see security merely as a temporary hurdle.
  2. That adoption of virtualization and cloud has implications on the relationship between IT Security and IT Ops, as the former focuses on governance and the latter on quality of service.

Both of these observations are spot on. The Keynote wasn’t a place to announce how to secure the cloud, or what RSA is doing here to further the effort, but this is obviously where RSA (and VMware and EMC) are in a great position to develop leadership.

Jon also analyzes Cisco’s Secure Borderless Network strategy.

K. Scott Morrison reviews the Cloud Security Alliance’s paper in his The Seven Deadly Sins: The Cloud Security Alliance Identifies Top Cloud Security Threats post of 3/1/2010 from the RSA Conference:

Today marks the beginning of RSA conference in San Francisco, and the Cloud Security Alliance (CSA) has been quick out of the gate with the release of its Top Threats to Cloud Computing Report. This peer-reviewed paper characterizes the top seven threats to cloud computing, offering examples and remediation steps.

The seven threats identified by the CSA are:

  1. Abuse and Nefarious Use of Cloud Computing
  2. Insecure Application Programming Interfaces
  3. Malicious Insiders
  4. Shared Technology Vulnerabilities
  5. Data Loss/Leakage
  6. Account, Service, and Traffic Hijacking
  7. Unknown Risk Profile

Some of these will certainly sound familiar, but the point is to highlight threats that may be amplified in the cloud, as well as those that are unique to the cloud environment.

Scott concludes:

… The latest survey results, and the threats paper itself, are available from the CSA web site. Bear in mind that is evolving work. The working group intends to update the list regularly, so if you would like to make a contribution to the cloud community, please do get involved. And remember: CSA membership is free to individuals; all you need to give us is your time and expertise.

James Urquhart’s The cloud cannot ignore geopolitics post of 3/1/2010 to C|Net News’ Wisdom of Clouds blog begins:

Cloud computing is an operations model, not a technology: that critical fact underpins so many of the challenges and advantages that cloud computing models place upon distributed applications.

It is the reason that so many existing application architecture concepts work in the cloud, and it is the reason that so many developers are forced to address aspects of those architectures that they could skimp on or even ignore in the self-contained bubble of traditional IT.

One of the most fascinating aspects of cloud's architectural forcing function is the way it forces developers to acknowledge the difference between two often conflicting "realities" that applications must live in; that of the physical world we humans live in each day, and that of the computing world, consisting of electronics, wires, and its own set of rules, captured in software form. …

(Graphic credit: cc Doug/Picasa)

James concludes:

… In cloud computing, "virtual" geography and "physical" geography are both extremely important, and it's up to humans to keep the two aligned. Because this is complex and prone to error, it may be one of the great business opportunities to come out of the disruption that cloud computing is wreaking on IT practices.

Brenda Michelson comments on James Urquhart’s article in her James Urquhart: It’s not (just) the data destination, it’s also the journey post of 3/2/2010:

Per usual, James Urquhart published a thought provoking post on cloud computing and geopolitics.  Recently, as part of my 100-day cloud watch, I’ve pointed out the importance of cloud computing environment location in respect to data residence.  In his post, James goes further, or perhaps better stated, starts earlier.  Raising awareness on the paths that data travels, to reach its destination: 

“How would an application operator deploy applications at a minimum "distance" from users in a network sense, without finding themselves passing data through a country that would jeopardize the safety of that data? Again, the path your data takes between two physical locations may not be the path you expected.

You are already seeing some examples of how the governments and corporations are trying to mold the Internet and "the cloud" to fit into human geopolitical realities. Countries like China, Iran, Pakistan, and others have demonstrated their willingness to control the Internet transoms over their nation’s borders, and to apply technology to controlling the "border traffic" at those crossing points.”

In his post, James makes some great observations on computing versus world boundaries, and poses a challenge for cloud computing, networking, business and political leaders:

“What’s missing, however, is any form of formal infrastructure within the Internet/Intercloud itself to "automate" mapping the human world to the computer world. Is this even possible, I often wonder. Can we (or, more to the point, should we) try to "codify" the laws and regulations of the world into digital form, allowing computer networks and applications to self-regulate?

What would the political fallout of such a system be?

In cloud computing, "virtual" geography and "physical" geography are both extremely important, and it’s up to humans to keep the two aligned. Because this is complex and prone to error, it may be one of the great business opportunities to come out of the disruption that cloud computing is wreaking on IT practices.”

Read his post.  Remember it’s not just the destination, but also the journey that counts.

See SearchCloudComputing.com’s RSA has its head in the cloud on opening day of 3/1/2010 in the Cloud Computing Events section.

<Return to section navigation list> 

Cloud Computing Events

Geva Perry describes Migration to the Cloud: CloudConnect Panel in this 3/2/2010 post:

The excellent CloudConnect conference is coming up in Santa Clara, California, March 15-18. There is a lot of excitement around this event, as the content seems excellent and many people are coming into the Bay Area for this event.

As a matter of fact, the San Francisco Cloud Computing Club is also having a meetup around the event on Tuesday, March 16 at 6:30 pm with many "clouderati" expected to participate. Should be fun.

Back to CloudConnect, on March 16 at 1:30 PM, I'll be participating in a panel moderated by Randy Bias (@randybias), which is part of the Cloud Computing Migration track at the conference. Below are the official details and Randy provides additional background on the CloudScaling blog.

Moving to Clouds: It's Not All or Nothing  - Panel

Join Me at CloudConnectYou're ready to embrace cloud computing. You can move your IT to on-demand public clouds, and reap the benefits of elasticity; or you can create on-premise clouds that make you more agile and efficient while keeping control of data. The only thing you can't afford to do is keep using old-fashioned IT. But when it's time to adopt a cloud strategy, the options can be daunting. Do you need a public cloud? Private? Both? Should you use a platform or an infrastructure cloud? Which applications are candidates for cloud deployment?

In this opening session, you'll learn the differences between public and private clouds, and the factors you need to consider when planning a migration to cloud-based IT.

  • Moderator Randy Bias, Founder, Cloudscaling
  • Speaker Ellen Rubin, VP of Products, CloudSwitch
  • Speaker Geva Perry, Author, Thinking Out Cloud
  • Speaker Victoria Livschitz, CEO, GridDynamics
  • Speaker Tom Gregory, CTO, Presidio Health

I’m planning to be at the conference and the San Francisco Cloud Computing Club meetup.

Jeremy Geelan reports Cloud Computing Bootcamp Returns to New York City April 20, 2010 in this 3/1/2010 post:

No one can properly understand anything related to enterprise-level Cloud Computing without having first gained a reasonable understanding of the very basics.

SYS-CON's pioneering Cloud Computing Bootcamp is designed with that in mind. It is a one-day, fully immersive deep-dive into the Cloud, in which the sessions during the day seek to deal with real problems and look at alternative solutions.

Click Here to Register Now for Cloud Computing Bootcamp 2010 East and Save!

The ever-popular Bootcamp, which is now held regularly around the world, is being held next in conjunction the 5th Cloud Expo in New York, NY (April 20, 2010). It is led by software industry entrepreneur and Bootcamp Instructor Alan Williamson.

Attending delegates will leave the Bootcamp with resources, ideas and examples they can apply immediately.

The SearchCloudComputing.com staff claims RSA has its head in the cloud on opening day in this 3/1/2010 post:

The giant paranoia-for-profit fest known as the RSA Conference kicked off today in San Francisco, and cloud computing is drawing heavy interest. The Cloud Security Alliance's five-hour session was reportedly turning people away at the door for the keynote.

The CSA announced a peer-reviewed paper, entitled "Top Threats to Cloud Computing," that outlines major challenges to providing and using cloud computing. Its choice for number one was the "abuse and nefarious use" of cloud to provide spammers and bot herders access to massive pools of computing firepower. Number two was insecurity at the technical level for cloud providers who didn't mind their APIs, and number three was "malicious insiders."

"This threat is amplified for consumers of cloud services," it said.

The report cited the lack of transparency and highly automated use of clouds as a reason to fear a provider's employees, much as one might fear the janitor at the gym; only with cloud computing, you're not encouraged to bring your own lock. Fortunately, or perhaps worrisome, "No public examples are available at this time." …

<Return to section navigation list> 

Other Cloud Computing Platforms and Services

David Linthicum asserts “2010 will clearly be the year of cloud consolidation, so you need to be careful where and how you place your cloud computing bets” in his Cloud provider roulette: Will yours still be around? post of 3/2/2010 to InfoWorld’s Cloud Computing blog:

I was not surprised to see that CA has bought cloud infrastructure provider 3Tera -- I believe that 2010 will be the year of cloud consolidation, and we've only just begun.

This is CA's third major acquisition that targets cloud computing, including Cassatt last summer and Oblicore earlier this year. CA has long been a company that purchases its way into a space, and apparently cloud computing will be no different than other emerging areas that CA has entered through acquisition.

3Tera offers both public and private cloud infrastructures, available in a choice of cloud service or on-premise software. With this purchase, CA now has a true public cloud in its portfolio, and that's a very different model than its core enterprise software business.

The larger issue here is that we're entering into a buying frenzy around cloud computing technology, both public and private. I suspect we'll see this accelerate as stock prices continue to rebound, and thus management feels much better about entering into riskier deals. …

Dave concludes with this advice:

… If you are evaluating cloud computing technology today, you have to consider that your choice could be bought up this year or next. That means you need to make sure your legal agreements are rock-solid and spell out what happens if your provider is acquired. In other words, you need to make sure that having a different cloud landlord won't affect your business. Good luck all.

John Treadway adds to David Linthicum’s post with prescriptive advice for use of open-source cloud systems in his Protecting Yourself from Cloud Provider & Vendor Roulette post of 3/1/2010:

David Linthicum wrote a piece today in InfoWorld regarding the coming wave of cloud vendor consolidation.  After CA’s acquisition of 3Tera, it’s natural to ask how you can protect yourself from having your strategic vendor acquired by a larger, less focused entity.  Face it, the people building these startups are mostly hoping to have the kind of success that 3Tera had — a reported $100m payday.  A lot of people are concerned with what CA will do with AppLogic – their general history with young technologies is not particularly promising.  If you are building a cloud, AppLogic is the heart of your system.  If CA screws it up (and I’m not saying they will, but if they do…), you’re pretty much hosed.

As I wrote in November, we will start seeing both consolidation and market exits in the cloud provider in the not too distant future.  So, whether you are building a cloud, or using someone else’s cloud, you need to have a plan to mitigate the all-too-real risks of your vendor going away or having a change of control event (e.g. being acquired) that results in a degraded capability.

If  you’re building a cloud (private or public), the primary way you can protect yourself is by selecting a vendor with an open source model.  If the commercial entity fails, you can still count on the community to move the product forward – or you can step in and become the commercial sponsor.  If the vendor gets acquired and the new owner takes the project in a direction you don’t want, you can “fork” the project (see Drizzle and MariaDB as forks of the MySQL project owned by Oracle as a result of the Sun acquisition).  Or, you can start with a community-sponsored project like OpenNebula that has a very open license (Apache).  It is highly unlikely that OpenNebula will go away anytime soon, and due to the licensing model there is no chance the a vendor will get deep control of the project.

John Rymer claims Oracle Likes Cloud Computing After All in this 3/1/2010 post to the Forrester Research blog for Application Development and Program Management Professionals:

Larry Ellison angrily dismisses suggestions that Oracle’s business will be harmed by the rise of cloud computing. Many misinterpret Ellison’s remarks to mean he (and by extension Oracle) thinks cloud computing is a dumb idea that Oracle won’t pursue. We are now learning that Oracle does, in fact, intend to pursue cloud computing. But we're also learning that Oracle's strategy is more limited than those of IBM and Microsoft, its large-vendor competitors.

I attended the San Francisco Oracle Cloud Computing Forum on February 25, 2010 -- one of 51 such events Oracle is running worldwide. Oracle described a strategy that is pragmatic for Oracle, but not well-articulated and missing key pieces.

PRAGMATIC: Oracle’s approach to cloud computing has three major parts:

  1. If you want an internal, or private, cloud, Oracle will sell you the hardware and/or middleware to build it.
  2. If you want to use Oracle’s software on a third-party cloud, Oracle supports Amazon Web Services and Rackspace Cloud today, and will support other clouds in the future.
  3. If you want to rent rather than own Oracle’s business applications, Oracle will provide those apps under a hosted subscription model.

This strategy seeks to adapt Oracle’s current business modes and products to the concepts of cloud computing. To Oracle, internal clouds are a new data-center architecture, public clouds are a new sales channel, and cloud-based applications (SaaS) are new business terms. There’s no new operating system (a la Microsoft Windows Azure), no new development model (a la Salesforce’s Force.com), no commitment to provide public cloud platform services (a la IBM and Microsoft).

Oracle described a two-step process to move from today’s typical architectures to internal clouds that makes sense (see figure) -- and starts with adoption of Oracle's "grid" products. This progression makes sense, but not as easy as Oracle makes it sound. To be fair, most vendors understate the difficulty of transition from today's data centers to internal clouds.Oracle's 2 steps to cloud

John continues with an analysis of the Oracle Private PaaS offering.

Eric Beeler writes “The idea of the private cloud provides a lot of promise, but the technology is not cheap. Here's what vendors can actually offer today -- and how much it will cost” as a preface to his Building a Private Cloud article for Redmond Magazine of 3/1/2010:

… Vendors are defining the private cloud, so every vendor has a different take on the meaning of this new approach to computing resources. The big reasons to move toward a private cloud include automation and utilization. Companies have been moving data centers toward virtualization to save money by increasing utilization of the computers they already own. The private cloud elevates this concept not only by virtualizing servers, but also by turning virtual machines (VMs) into a pool of resources that can be provisioned on demand with minimal manual intervention.

In addition, it allows for a type of on-demand response to needs by moving resources to where they're needed quickly. Some vendors take that model and extend it to public cloud resources and address the typical multi-tenant model to try to satisfy security, usability and performance concerns unique to enterprise IT. Whatever the definition, what an organization is trying to do is harness better utilization of computing power and ease administration requirements with better control over the environment.

Eric continues with vendor assessments of Amazon, IBM, Microsoft, and VMware private-cloud offerings.

John Brodkin claims “CloudSwitch moves applications to cloud service” in his Cloud computing start-up creates secure tunnel between data center and Amazon cloud post of 3/1/2010 to NetworkWorld’s Cloud Computing community:

A start-up that moves VMware-based applications to the Amazon cloud and creates a secure tunnel between a customer's data center and the cloud service is launching a public beta trial Monday.

CloudSwitch, recently out of stealth mode, moves existing applications from internal data centers to the cloud without rewriting the app or requiring changes in management tools.

The concept is not a new one. Amazon's Virtual Private Cloud and the vendor CohesiveFT both tackle the goal of bridging the internal data center with public cloud services in a secure manner.

But CloudSwitch is unique in offering a service that takes care of all the networking, isolation, management, security and storage concerns related to moving an existing application to a cloud, says The 451 Group analyst William Fellows. Still, CloudSwitch has yet to demonstrate a real-world example of its technology in action, so there are still questions about the mechanism of deployment and user experience, he says.

"There are still some question marks around the operation of a CloudSwitch environment," Fellows says. "A lot of details are still quite closely held." …

<Return to section navigation list>